Alrighty, so I have a general update on my situation as of this time.
EverDrive sent to Krikzz Certified Reseller and confirmed as faultyAt the beginning of April, I sent back my EverDrive to Stone Age Gamer (SAG) on their recommendation. They had confirmed that there was something indeed wrong with how short the playtime was on their test GBA units.
Although, they weren't able to confirm what component(s) were causing the issue, the SAG service representative told me that "the defective cart will be sent back to krikzz and we'll include some of the info you provided to them so they can take a look at it and hopefully that will help them figure out what went wrong in the first place."
@Krikzz - Perhaps later if you/your associates receives this cartridge for review, you may be able share what happened. I'm genuinely curious, and if it helps others troubleshoot their carts, that's awesome too.
Replacement Cartridge sent by Reseller; Received and TestedNow before SAG sent me the replacement, they actually took the time to test this cartridge before sending it to me. It was when they were testing the length of playtime on the replacement cartridge against my original cartridge where they had mentioned that the presence of a problem became apparent.
Nevertheless, I still took some time to test the replacement cartridge in a few scenarios.
Cartridge Info: EverDrive x5 Mini, OS 1.15, BL 1.03
Diagnostics: All tests came back as OK
Console: GBA SP (AGS-101) Backlight default brightness, 50% volume
Battery: Tomee 400 mAH
SD Card: Patriot LX Series 16GB CL10 SDHC
Game: Everdrive x5 Mini (Metroid: Fusion)
Trial 1: 296 mins
Game: Stock GBA Cartridge (Metroid: Fusion)
Trial 1: 316 mins
I also took some time to test the cartridge in my GameBoy Player using GBI under Swiss OS, everything worked great.
So holy s**t, the difference between my replacement and original cartridges are like night and day. This is the experience I was expecting when getting an EverDrive based on the other products I've gotten from Krikzz. It was a bit of an arduous journey to get here, but I'm glad that it worked out.
I'd like to thank everyone for the support and advice I was provided on this thread and through all the private messages I got. I hope this info ends up helping others that get stuck in this situation.